Actually, I'm not really sure what to say in this post, because the movie has left me a little bit speechless. From the beginning of the movie, about a million questions were running through my mind..in fact, I wrote them all down and tried to find answers for them throughout the movie. Some were answered...others were not --which isn't always a bad thing, considering leaving certain things open for the imagination can make plots more terrifying a times.
I liked the overall setting of the story -- to me, snow storms are a perfect environment to breed chaos because you have that constant feeling of isolation, entrapment, loneliness, and my personal favorite, cabin fever. This appeals to me because of the psychological trials and tribulations that come with it -- in other words, I love to watch the human mind break down. That's probably why I liked The Shining so much. Seeing Jack Torence go back and forth between the forces that were penetrating his mind was fascinating to me, so in this case, watching the breakdown of the group was what roped me into the movie.
I always thought an invisible creature, and/or attack strategy would be the worst because you would never know what was going to happen at any given time, thus making the concept of of protecting yourself rather difficult. However, this movie showed me that a monster that could imitate humans to perfection is without a doubt worse. Everyone ends up being accused, no one can be trusted, and the group is in a constant state of panic. Imagine shooting your friend on sight, because they make, what you think to be, an different twitch than normal. It's mind-blowing to me, and when McGrady shot Carter because he snuck up behind him... my mouth dropped. This leads me to a major issue that I had with the movie though: the character's emotional detchment.
To me, it seemed like none of the characters showed any emotions throughout the entire movie...including fear at some points. For instance, in the beginning when they first encounter the creature, they just respond like it's no big deal. Something that they see everyday. Also, in the very beginning scene where the guy gets shot in the leg...he just shakes it off, and drinks a beer. It's like it was a feather rubbing against him or something. This continued to some level throughout the rest of the movie, and it really irritated me. I was glad at the end, when McGrady went nuts and threatened to blow the place up because it finally showed some hint of reality to me.
Now for some of the questions that are still left unanswered to me:
Plus, some of the overall problems with the movie:
- Where did Blair get all of these stats and information from? It just seemed like he figured everything out to easily to me. Also, in regards to the computers, why do they always have a female voice? Same thing happens in Resident Evil. Sexist?
- Lets talk about how this is the weirdest physical compilation of a monster I have ever seen. What was this thing in its original form? It looked like a hybrid from every monster even invented. and I hated it. It was cool when it would imitate people and then take on that level of fear, but the entire essence of it before it did so was really strange to me. Also, the creature grew entirely too fast in the scene with the dogs. It just kept sprouting tendrils, and legs, and then ejected this flower like head from its torso...I don't know, it just seemed like bad monster making to me.
- But while we are on the topic of the dogs, let's have a serious conversation. I firmly believe that it is a serious mistake to kill/torture dogs in the horror genre, because it really upsets and turns a lot of people off from your book/poem/script etc. No matter what movie I have watched, I have always been really tempted to quit watching it if a dog was brutalized. Secret Window really rubbed me the wrong way, when the dog was killed via a screwdriver to the head. I just don't think its a wise move for horror writers because it's going to kill a big chunk of your audience
I will say this though...while the blood looked horrifically fake, I LOVED the opening scene where they found the guy with his throat slit, and the dripping blood had turned into icicles. Very artistic!